Submit Hint Search The Forums LinksStatsPollsHeadlinesRSS
14,000 hints and counting!

Click here to return to the 'A finicky feature indeed' hint
The following comments are owned by whoever posted them. This site is not responsible for what they say.
A finicky feature indeed
Authored by: SOX on Sep 21, '06 09:42:30AM

I was able to import duplicates by draggin whole folders that containd duplicates in, even without the option key presses.

Interestingly this duplicate preventer makes a very bad mistake. It appears that it must base duplicates on the ID3 tags since it's not file name dependendent. It's easily possible to have two songs with identical ID3 tags that are not identical music. In my case for example, I had a song I had clipped the quenten tantentio style dialog from the beggining. In another case I had cutdown a long radio broadcast to a short web-ready segment. It would not import either of these because the original with the same ID3 tags was in place.

So in a nut shell: it does not prevent adding duplicates if they are added as multiple songs at the same time (as in a folder or import command) and it makes mistakes.

Nor does it find less stringent forms of duplicates (e.g. find duplicates by name only). For that see "corral dupes" over on Dougadams site. (guess you already knew that one doug!)

[ Reply to This | # ]
A finicky (dubious?) feature indeed
Authored by: DougAdams on Sep 21, '06 10:47:42AM

Yo, SOX: dubious "feature" perhaps, eh? ;)

I believe that iTunes bases duplication-when-adding on the filename. Perhaps ID3 data is considered as well. Since aliases are so cool, I imagine that iTunes knows that you have changed the file name of a track and knows that it's the same file. I tried dnd'ing a changed-filename file and it wouldn't add it, so perhaps ID3 data is a factor. Am I incorrect: if you change a Song Name, iTunes *may* change its filename if you have "Keep organized" checked. Afterall, iTunes tries to keep track of your music library files...wasn't that a complaint about 8 versions ago?

Doug's AppleScripts for iTunes

[ Reply to This | # ]