Submit Hint Search The Forums LinksStatsPollsHeadlinesRSS
14,000 hints and counting!

Click here to return to the 'How to work with an external editor in iPhoto' hint
The following comments are owned by whoever posted them. This site is not responsible for what they say.
How to work with an external editor in iPhoto
Authored by: osxpounder on Feb 10, '06 03:37:35PM

That's interesting [your discovery that RAW files get passed to Photoshop as JPGs]. I don't use RAW, but I tried a PSD file and find that it gets passed as a PSD no matter how I choose to edit it [click, context menu, whatever].

But it made me realize that I wish iPhoto would show the file extensions, so I could see at a glance that this thumbnail is a PSD, but that thumb's a JPG. I checked menus and prefs, but find no way to do it. That amazes me. Is it true that iPhoto won't show you file extensions, or am I missing how to enable this?


[ Reply to This | # ]
How to work with an external editor in iPhoto
Authored by: hamarkus on Feb 10, '06 04:28:15PM

In the source pane you can pull up an info window, there you can see the file type. Or do a command I.

[ Reply to This | # ]
How to work with an external editor in iPhoto
Authored by: derPlau on Feb 10, '06 05:09:40PM

The fact that PSD files are always sent to Photoshop as PSD files is partly due to the different way iPhoto treats RAW from the way it treats other image formats. When you edit a photo in iPhoto, it always keeps the original unchanged in the Originals folder and changes a copy of that original, which it places in the Modified folder. With every format except RAW, the copy it makes is of the same format as the original -- so there will be two photos called, say, IMG_001.psd; one in the Originals folder and one in the Modified folder. With RAW, however, the copy that gets saved is a different format from the original -- specifically, a jpg. This is to conform to the "RAW philosophy", which treats RAW as a digital negative that should never be edited directly.

So Osxpounder's observation made sense to me: if dragging the image to the Dock icon sends the original, while using the "Edit in external editor" menu item sends the modified copy, then RAW files would be sent as a different format via the two methods, while other files would be sent as the same format.

Interestingly, though, it turns out iTunes seems to be more intelligent than I expected: with RAW files, dragging to the dock icon sends the original; while with other files it sends the modified copy. I tested this (with a psd, in fact) by importing a file to iPhoto, editing it in an obvious way (I sepia'd it), then dragging the file -- lo & behold, the sepia version was what got opened in Photoshop! Pretty fascinating behavior.

[ Reply to This | # ]