Submit Hint Search The Forums LinksStatsPollsHeadlinesRSS
14,000 hints and counting!


Click here to return to the 'Interoperability and FAT32' hint
The following comments are owned by whoever posted them. This site is not responsible for what they say.
Interoperability and FAT32
Authored by: krishna on Jan 03, '03 02:26:13AM

One point made to me by my friends was that if you want an external
firewire/USB drive to be readable and writeable under MacOSX, Linux, and
Windows NT/2000/others, the firewire drive should be formatted as
FAT32. I don't believe any other filesystem format allows the
ability to read and write from all three operating systems.

One thing to note is that I wasn't able to format FAT32 partitions
of larger than ~30GB (at least under Windows 2000), so I had to
break an 80gB drive into 30gB/30gB/20gB sized partitions under Windows 2000
before I could format them. But once I partitioned the drive
and formatted the partitions, I could plug the drive
into my TiBook and see all the FAT32 partitions, and write to them.



[ Reply to This | # ]
Interoperability and FAT32
Authored by: sixthring on Jan 03, '03 08:09:58AM

You need to install the latest service packs for windows 2000 then you can very large hard drive partitions (greater than 30GB).



[ Reply to This | # ]
Interoperability and FAT32 and firewire problems.
Authored by: jelwell on Jan 03, '03 03:42:16PM

This is simply not true. Windows 2000 and Windows XP won't let you format a drive using FAT 32 if it's larger than 30gigs because Microsoft wants you to use NTFS. If you format the drive using Windows 98 or even a Windows 2000/XP installation cd, your Windows 2000/XP will read the drive just fine. Microsoft decided to implement this arbitrary limit to try to get people to migrate to NTFS to make it harder for people to leave windows, and to mitigate problems with FAT32.

Suggestions for formatting a large FAT32 drive:
1) Use linux to format the drive.
2) Try Partition Magic or similar product, some of these have arbitrary limits as well, but usually larger than your average Windows OS.
3) Use Windows 98 with an updated service pack.
4) Use your Windows 2000/XP install cd and pretend to install Windows on the hard drive, it will ask you to format the drive and it will let you choose fat32 even for large devices.

Some interesting tips on using large firewire drives. DO NOT try to connect to a Mac OS 10.1 machine! For some odd reason my 100gig firewire drive cannot be understood by OS 10.1 but Jaguar (10.2) works just fine. At first I thought it was my drive, but it's a generic housing and putting smaller ~20gig drives in it works just fine.

Also trying to connect my titanium powerbook as an external firewire drive to a 10.1 desktop fails miserably (hold the T button down while booting your laptop to make it act as an external firewire device). But when I updated my desktops to Jaguar suddenly my laptop and my 100gig firewire drive worked just fine. I think there is a bug with large external firewire drives connecting to OS 10.1

Joseph Elwell.



[ Reply to This | # ]
Interoperability and FAT32 and firewire problems.
Authored by: dave1212 on Jan 10, '03 05:59:40PM
Hmm.. Thanks for the insight! This could be just the thing I'm looking for.. I was unable to see my roomate's 40 GB under Target Disk Mode under 10.1 (he's running 9.2.1) but could see his 6 GB drive just fine..

Now, the thing is.. he was told that his 40 GB is a SCSI drive, and after some searching on apple's site and xlr8yourmac.com, I found that TDM doesn't support SCSI (yet). The real issue here is that when I opened his mac to look at the drive, it doesn't sat SCSI on it at all, and seems to use the built-in IDE and power cords that are part of the default G4.

It wouldn't be a problem if I didn't have both my IDE and power plug taken up by my two drives, both of which need to access his 40 GB...

Any help would be appreciated!

Thanks.

[ Reply to This | # ]
Interoperability and FAT32
Authored by: keitme on Jan 04, '03 10:29:33AM

The limit for a FAT32 partition is 2 terabytes under Windows 9x OS's. The maximum size that can be used under Windows 2000 is 32 gigabytes (This is a limitiation of the file system driver for Windows 2000). Windows XP can only format a FAT32 partition up to 32 gigabytes at the time it is installed, but once up and running the maximum size it will format is 2 terabytes.

So if you want to interoperate with a 2k box, 32 gigabytes is the limit.

The maximum size for a single file on a FAT32 partition is 4 gigabytes.
NTFS has a maximum partition size and file size of 16 exabytes.



[ Reply to This | # ]
Interoperability and FAT32
Authored by: adaronoff on Nov 05, '03 10:58:08AM

In PANTHER how do you mount the disk for write enable??

Thank you



[ Reply to This | # ]