Submit Hint Search The Forums LinksStatsPollsHeadlinesRSS
14,000 hints and counting!


Click here to return to the 'FQDN change to hints.macworld.com' hint
The following comments are owned by whoever posted them. This site is not responsible for what they say.
FQDN change to hints.macworld.com
Authored by: Andrew J Freyer on Aug 19, '10 03:22:44PM

I really do not understand the hate here - to no longer using a site because it slightly modifies its name? Sounds like your loyalty was to a brand and not the content. I find that position to be absurd.

Frankly, it shouldn't matter what a website is called so long as the content is valuable. Thanks to search engines, everyone anywhere looking for answers to their Mac issues will still be able to find this site, and because of the redirect, so will everyone who had a bookmark. How many of you would have noticed but for this disclosure?

My advice is to turn your passions to a more worthwhile cause.

---
Easier location-based computing: with Airport Location, app for 10.6. It's an early Beta, so please report bugs!



[ Reply to This | # ]
FQDN change to hints.macworld.com
Authored by: robleach on Aug 19, '10 04:25:35PM

But the content is from the community, that's why identity is so important. That's why when big companies merge, they keep the more valuable name. A reputation is built up associated with that name. What if McDonald's changed it's name to "Bert's Burger Bowl". Anyone driving down the strip is gonna stop at Burger King because they don't recognize "Bert's Burger Bowl". Political candidates can get elected on "name recognition" alone. I'm not "hating" here. I'm gonna keep coming. I'm not that fickle, but I think it's worth a discussion.

There's a subtle, but important connection being made here in people's heads. They discover something cool on this site called macosxhints.com, then they discover another cool thing. Before you know it, they start mentioning it to friends. Somewhere down the line, someone who's never used macosxhints.com before goes to look for it, but they end up somewhere else and think "I guess it went away" or "someone else bought it out" and they move on.

I want to support this site because I read it every day. I want more people to contribute. A lot of the sense of community is tied up in the name, whether it makes sense to you or not. What if someone renamed your favorite pet that you've had for years? Would it feel weird to you to call it something else? That's because it's your pet and you didn't rename it, someone else did. It doesn't feel right. Maybe we can get used to it, but my point is that the site is the community, so the community's sense of identification with the site is important and something a company should try to cultivate because it benefits them.

I sympathize with Craig and I don't doubt he's doing his best. Perhaps I'm wrong - I hope so - but I think changing the name is not the best of ideas. I'll be interested to see where this goes.

Rob



[ Reply to This | # ]